Second Will Become First
The IDF’s new faceToday, army’s combat troops dominated by names like Oleg and Muhammad
Eitan HaberWelcome to the IDF 2008. The combat forces of this IDF are made up of, mostly, residents of outlaying areas, the children of new immigrants from Russia and the former Soviet Union, Bedouins, Druze – what we used to refer to as “the second Israel” once upon a time. Well, that “second Israel” has moved up.
When we look at the casualties of the latest military operations, and maybe even before that, we can see the IDF’s up-to-date image: Oleg, Leonid, Maxim, Peter, Ahmed, Muhammad, Wahid, Wasim. Their parents live in places like Kiryat Gat, Afula, Horfish, and the al-Huzeil tribe.
Meanwhile, the dictionary of names saw the disappearance of the likes of Ran and Shahar and Shahak, Tsafrir and Segev and Yinon, Gonen and Netzer, just like we saw the disappearance of Herzliya and Ramat Hasharon, Tel Aviv and Netanya, Ramat Gan, Bnei Zion, and Bnei Atarot.
Tough tests aheadThis does not mean, heaven forbid, that there are no combat soldiers these days who come from the abovementioned communities and from other places. There certainly some, even many, and they are good ones – yet the “trend,” the direction, and the tone in the IDF today are set by members of the “second Israel.”
If you think about it, IDF Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi is also an example of this – the son of immigrant parents, grew up in a moshav community, a member of the Golani Brigade, which for generations has elicited praise but was not considered for a long time as the army’s “cream of the crop.” Many of Ashkenazi’s predecessors were from the country’s “Mayflower” families and came from what were considered the true elite units.
Is this good for the IDF? We should hope and assume that it is. In any case, nobody can change this trend. We should accept it as it is and do everything in order to become better, because there are apparently still difficult tests ahead of us.
Leaders in Israel have always said that the “current generation” is better than their own generation when it comes to the military and to civilian life. Now, the burden of proof is on the “current generation.”
Want to know why the face of the IDF has changed, because you and your type are elitist Ashkenazim that have taught values to your kids that make them want nothing to do with paying the price for having a Jewish state.
Your boys would rather kiss their boy friends than have comrades in arms that they share the burden of battle with, or at the vary least your children seek to be the "beautiful souls" that want to identify with the poor Palestinians .
On the other side you have the religious Zionist, children of the Moshavs and settlements along with the Druze who are building a strong IDF to protect Israel well into the future.
You cry for the fact your kibbutz and communist sons don't serve but point and some do and they are " good ones" and then you whine about what you call the "Second Israel", about how we have a Chief of Staff that for the first time was not part of Sayeret Matkal.
When we have buried the last elitist snob like you it will be us the "Second Israel" that will be fighting in the IDF and living in Israel.

